Merola cobalt blue porcelain penny round, Home Depot, $6.95 sq. ft.
Merola cobalt blue porcelain square tile, Home Depot, $6.50 sq. ft.
Merola blue cloud porcelain pebble, Home Depot, about $7 sq. ft. (Kev thinks these may just look cheap in person)
Luxetile 2" ceramic blue hexagon, $5.95 sq. ft. (minimum order 100 sq. ft.)
Luxetile 3/4" porcelain blue hexagon mosaic, $7.30 sq. ft. (minimum order 50 sq. ft.)
I need to call tomorrow to find out if the latter two are floor-rated. And I need to see samples in person. But I definitely prefer the look of these to the Menard's tiles. What do you think?